Have You Ever Driven a Stolen Rental Car?

My dad wrote to me about a friend’s interesting predicament during a recent car rental. There are lots of stories about people renting a car and then stealing it, often trying to sell it to someone else. Or perhaps someone is found driving a car they thought was purchased legally and it turns out it’s stolen property.

In this case, my dad’s friend rented his car legitimately from Hertz, did nothing wrong, and yet apparently the local police thought his vehicle was stolen. The police stopped him in a residential area, drew their weapons, cuffed him, and put him in the back seat of their patrol car.

Hertz receipt screenshot

Needless to say, Hertz waived the cost of the rental. That’s the $179.76 “Customer Relations Expense.” It’s hard to tell exactly what went wrong. Did Hertz report the vehicle stolen before renting it out to someone else? Maybe they had an issue with a previous renter and failed to retract the report. Did Hertz unknowingly purchase a stolen vehicle and add it to their fleet? My dad’s friend hasn’t gotten many answers. It’s not a situation most people experience, so I’m curious to know if you’ve ever heard of something similar. One thing’s for sure: I’d probably demand a lot more than $180 in compensation.

About Scott Mackenzie

Scott founded HMT while traveling on a budget during graduate school and stays loyal to United, Alaska, Hyatt, and Starwood.
Email // Twitter // Facebook // Google+ // Subscribe by RSS

  • http://twitter.com/aadvantageGeek AAdvantage Geek

    Did he end up going to jail?

    • Turd Furguson.

      Yes and he is never coming back.

    • Scottrick

      No. Luckily the cops figured out that he hadn’t really stolen the car.

  • Sice

    Seems like he should get lifetime President’s Circle membership and a few free rentals every year. Maybe lifetime access to some employee discount code or something. Someone made a mistake, so Hertz should pay the price but shouldn’t be overly penalized, but they should treat him like they value his business and this way would be pretty cheap for them and would make a big difference to him.

  • Matt

    Keep it mind it could have been a problem on the police’s end – wrong license plate put into database for example.

    • Scottrick

      I have an update planned for tomorrow. Suffice it to say for now that this was not the police’s issue. Hertz is responsible.

  • Daringdoo

    I was once contacted by a rental company, days after returning the car, asking if I still had it… Not sure how one proves they returned the car when the agency doesn’t give a receipt (or it’s after hours)!

    • Michelle S

      That thought crossed my mind when a Hertz in Mexico wouldn’t give me a receipt- said their printer and fax machines were down.

  • rc

    Not true. The police would verify with the car rental company before taking anyone into custody. Your friends dad may be have been in trouble with some other stuff that he is trying to cover up!

    • Scottrick

      I can tell you that he wasn’t arrested. They figured it out. But the whole guns drawn, stick-em-up really happened.

  • AKold

    Will he still earn bonus miles/points on the rental?

    • Scottrick

      That’s a very important question. Another is: Do the police have a frequent inmate loyalty program? :D

  • http://www.frequentflyeruniversity.com/ Frequent Flyer University

    This is the first time I have ever heard of something like this. Keep us updated on what compensation he gets.

  • ClearedCustoms

    This sounds like a great evening news soundbite. If this was the result of some action Hertz took I’d imagine there’s a lot more room for compensation.

  • amr2002

    This did actually happen to me in florida. But they didn’t draw guns or cuff us.. they pulled us over, and then we showed them the Hertz docs, and then we waited a while where everyone worked it out. It was still pretty weird.